Win a $100 Gift Certificate for Asics Shoes
Fit After Thirty
Apr
23
Is The Convenience Worth The Risk?

When I was on the birth control pill during part of my twenties, I told the gynecologist that I thought it had decreased my libido, made me less orgasmic, and turned me into a moody, emotional basket case. Just based on my common sense belief that anything that affects hormone levels could likely affect libido, I asked her innocently, “Can the pill cause those symptoms?”

As if she had stock in the very company that made them (and she probably did), she insisted that there was no evidence that the pill could cause any of the symptoms that I described.

I never researched it; I just chalked it up to her being stupid, went along my merry way and stopped taking the damn things. Thanks to incessant media coverage of the AIDS epidemic when I was a teen, I was already a diligent condom user, regardless of how much I trusted my boyfriend, so stopping the pill didn’t cause a disruption to my normal routine.

As it turns out, she was uneducated about the issue, because I now know that studies existed from years prior to that conversation, which reported the negative effects of oral contraceptives on sexual function, including diminished sexual interest and arousal, suppression of female initiated sexual activity, decreased frequency of sexual intercourse and sexual enjoyment. 

But a 2006 study in The Journal of Sexual Health goes one step further, in saying that the pill may have permanent negative effects on a woman’s health, leading to ongoing sexual, metabolic and mental health issues, even after pill use is stopped. 

Of chief concern is the effect on SHBG (sex hormone binding globulin) levels. The study, which compared women who never took the pill, women who were currently on it, and women who had stopped taking it, showed that in women with sexual dysfunction who had discontinued use of the pill, elevated levels of SHBG did not decrease to the levels that might be expected had they never taken the pill. 

Dr. Claudia Panzer, endocrinologist and lead author of the study said, ”An interesting observation was that the use of oral contraceptives led to changes in the synthesis of SHBG which were not completely reversible in our time frame of observation. This can lead to lower levels of ‘unbound’ testosterone, which is thought to play a major role in female sexual health.”

She added that longer term studies are needed to assess whether these increased SHBG changes are permanent, but researchers theorize that prolonged exposure to the synthetic estrogens of oral contraceptives induces gene imprinting and increased gene expression of SHBG in the liver.

I’ve said before that I think the birth control pill is absolute poison to a woman’s system and that in my opinion, the benefits do not outweigh the consequences of using it. I believe most women prefer hormonal contraception over condoms and the IUD, because they are unaware of the negative effects the pill has on their health. Maybe this will help make a few more of you aware!

6 Comments
 
April 23rd, 2009 at 9:02 am
 

Not everyone takes the pill for reasons that can be replaced with condoms or a non-hormonal IUD. Many women, myself included, are on it for health related issues, such as ovarian cysts. As someone who has had the unfortunate experience of winding up in the ER on two separate occasions due to a burst cyst, I am quite positive that the benefits of preventing the worst pain I have EVER been in in my entire life far outweigh any long-term side effects from being on the pill. By far.

As I am aware of the possible increase in SGHB levels, however, I do have blood work done on a yearly basis to see if mine have increased. Thus far since I have been on the pill, my levels have remained completely normal. Rather than telling women that the pill has negative consequences on their heath, perhaps it would be wise to suggest for those who do wish to remain on it, that they can look into having blood work done to look at their hormone levels to see if they are at risk from long term birth control use?

April 23rd, 2009 at 10:06 am
 

This is a very interesting article. I have been on birth control pills since prior to having sex. I know it’s hard for me to climax but I always thought I was just one of those girls that you have to put in little bit more work. Anyway I was off the pills for about year and I do remember at one point me being more sexual and willing to initiate. Since have the baby I’m on depo. So far I haven’t experience any side affects as describe, my sex life is finally getting back to normal. I never thought it would be related to the depo because I just had a baby and needed to get over some mental issues, like afraid to have another one, pain, and since I was nursing the lack of lubrication. Thank you for having so much information. I appreciate it.

Thickchick
April 25th, 2009 at 3:15 pm
 

Though I agree with you on many fronts, (I have experienced a significant drop in libido while on a few different previous hormonal birth control methods) I feel your opinion is rather one-sided. While many of us would rather not be on hormonal birth control, for whatever reason, (I don’t like pills of ANY kind, antibiotics, prescription pain meds - nothing) following the pain of an unplanned pregnancy, I definitely feel the need for a more fool-proof method than the diaphragm I used to rely on. Further, my doctor didn’t feel I was a good candidate for an IUD. Luckily, there are now MANY options for those that choose the pill, and with an extremely low dose version, I have yet to experience any negative side-effects. I do agree that women need to explore their options rather than just blindly signing up for hormonal birth control, which is often pushed by healthcare providers, but I do not think your advice suits everyone.

labgirl
May 1st, 2009 at 11:45 am
 

I went on the low dose pills for perimenopausal symptoms. Within two weeks I was so clinically depressed that I was trying to find ways to kill myself that wouldn’t completely traumatize my children. My husband threw the pills away, (we did contact a psychiatrist, as well as my OB, and because it was a holiday weekend, I was told to hang in there til Monday, and if I thought I was going to hurt myself to go to the hospital.) Yeah right. Thankfully, my spouse baby sat me all weekend and by Monday I was in control enough to not off myself. This past Monday I called my GP and asked for blood work (full hormone work-up)still waiting on results. The anxiety, depression and suicidal tendencies are still here though. I have never before those pills had a period of depression so deep I wanted to kill myself. I will live with the side effects of perimenopause. No more pills for me…ever!

Al
August 20th, 2009 at 12:40 pm
 

There are also some studies relating these pills to having negative effects on women’s fertility, linking the increase in fertility clinics to the hormonal effects of the pill. They are relatively young studies because it is believed that these effects develop over time, so the test groups are not as large in the older sectors, but it is very logical. When you think about the number of cases claiming that our milk, cheese, eggs, etc.. that are hormonally treated are creating the decrease in age of women physically and sexually maturing, it seems reasonable that something else added to our bodies that would effect our hormones so severly would end up having deeper effects as well.

Kristy
January 24th, 2010 at 3:23 pm
 

thank you for this article! it’s me! finally some research to back up what I have been going through! If women can get their blood work checked/hormone checks than that is great- for those of us that are beyond that, at least it’s re-assuring to know that more research is being done as a preventative measure-

Leave a Reply